TV / Film / Game Tie-Ins  > Other TV & Film

Steven Universe vol 1 (UK Edition)

Steven Universe vol 1 (UK Edition) back

Jeremy Sorese & Coleman Engle

Price: 
10.99

Page 45 Review by Jonathan

"Hmm... this strange crystal is definitely a test! Maybe a puzzle? To see if I can harness the power of super special gem!! I will discover all your secrets!!"
"Gasp!! Steven, what happened?!"
"Uuuuughm... I couldn't discover the secrets... I tried everything but I couldn't figure out the secrets of this special gem, I understand why you can't take me on missions."
"Ha ha ha!! Steven, it's not a gem."
"Huh?!"
"It's a disco ball."
CLICK!
"This is more amazing than I could ever have imagined."

Sadly it really isn't. How disappointing. I love Steven Universe the TV show but this isn't a patch on it. Surprisingly for a show with such clean animation, they have decided to employ an artist with a far looser style. Actually, it looks a little bit like Jen IN REAL LIFE Wang if I am being overly kind, but that's by the by. All the characters are recognisable but it just doesn't feel like the show.

Then, there is the fact that each single issue was a different short, well two actually, a colour one then a very short black and white one, which disrupts the reading process even further. To me, this title was begging for four- or six-issue story arcs, being illustrated exactly like the show. So it would then have been a perfect continuation of it. Instead it just feels like a cheap throwaway cash-in. Others may disagree.

I felt exactly the same about REGULAR SHOW, a programme I adore, but I can't even bring myself to look at the comics for precisely the same reasons. Incredibly short throwaway stories, little more than gag strips, which look nothing like the show. Having just checked, yep, that's the same artist as here, Coleman Engle. I feel harsh criticising someone who is clearly a very good artist. But they are just not the right fit for either of these titles. And if I wanted gag strips, I would read PEANUTS. Actually I wouldn't, I would read HYPERBOLE AND A HALF or CYANIDE AND HAPPINESS but hey ho, you get my point.

spacer